On manipulation

I work in the field of web design. Or ‘digital design’, or ‘UX’… whatever you’d like to call it, it means that I am paid to manipulate you. This manipulation generally has two goals:

And so we apply all the persuasion techniques we know (“Hurry, only 5 items left!”) and make active use of your cognitive biases, to make sure that you open your wallets and spend, spend, spend.

The problem lies therein that only a handful of people in web design seem to ask the ethics question: Where do we draw the line? Is it morally just to exploit your irrationalities and vulnerabilities? Isn’t it evil to purposefully make you addicted to our services (think: Facebook)?

Of course I have a responsibility in this myself, and in fact I have started such discussions in my own professional context. But as ethical behaviour usually limits a business’ potential for money making, these discussions are met with professionalism, but not enthusiasm.

This is really starting to wear me down, and partly why I am increasingly attracted to the field of architecture. Of course, architecture is full of manipulation as well. As architect Jan Gehl says:

“We manipulate the conditions of people’s lives […] We are manipulating every time we put down a stone.”

But there is a fundamental difference between the manipulating in web design and that in architecture:

In web design, design means ‘manipulating people for their money’. In architecture, design means ‘manipulating environments for people’s happiness’.

And I find the latter a much more attractive thought…

Index

1. UNDERSTANDING THE PROBLEM

On sustainability

2. UNDERSTANDING HOW THE WORLD WORKS

On nature

On human nature

On the meaning of life and living

On culture

On morality

3. UNDERSTANDING HOW CHANGE WORKS

On the Next Level Society

On behavioral change

On marketing sustainability

4-A. FIXING HOW WE DESIGN THE WORLD

On naturalness

On naturalness in behaviour

On naturalness in art

Artworks of interest

On naturalness in architecture

Architecture of interest: naturalness

On livable architecture

Architecture of interest: livability

On naturalness in design

Design works of interest

4-B. FIXING OUR RELATIONSHIP WITH OURSELVES

On well-being, self care and happiness

4-C. FIXING THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN BUSINESS AND SOCIETY

On responsible business

On Positive Design & design ethics

On privacy

Progressieve bureaus van Nederland, 2021

OTHER NOTES AND WRITINGS

On digital design, CX/UX, and technology

On the travel & hospitality industry

Miscellaneous

Other pages